Where to Purchase

Ebook » Paperback »

Our Review

‘Love could heal you, or it could destroy you. What was braver, or more foolish, than offering up your heart to someone and saying, ‘Take it. It’s yours. Treat it with care. It’s fragile and breakable.’

If you haven’t added the Lost Stars Series by Emery Rose to your TBR’s yet, we highly recommend immersing yourselves in the love lives of the McCallister brothers! We’re consumed by this series – these McCallister men certainly make a meal out of finding their soulmate, but when they do…they give everything they have making us swoon, cry and melt along the way.

When We Were Reckless is the third book in the Lost Stars Series, and it had it all – forbidden love, unrequited love, age gap, slow burn, brothers best friend’s little sister, sexual awakenings, and emotional growth – and we ate up every morsel of angst, heartache, love, and friendship.

‘He was my friend and my soul mate. He was everything I’d always dreamed he would be.
Unforgettable. Irreplaceable. The love of my life.
If only I could be his too.’

So far in the series, we’ve met Jude, Brody (their cousin), and now 27 year old, Jesse McCallister, the Moto Cross champ who finds love with Quinn Cavanagh, the 18-year-old little sister of his best friend Mason. Every book has captivated us from start to finish with When We Were Reckless being no exception. And you know what? We can’t contain our excitement for their brother, Gideon’s book!

Quinn Cavanaugh, has had a crush on Jesse McCallister since she was a little girl, and nothing has changed in 18 years. Jesse’s back in Cypress Springs, licking his wounds after an abrupt end to his Moto Cross career and a breakup with his girlfriend leaving him feeling lost and emotionally drained.

‘Fuck my life. Fuck her for making me fantasise about her. Worry about her. Want to do everything in my power to protect her.’

Quinn is biding her time over the summer before beginning her College life at UCLA – and Jesse returning home. Being in the same vicinity as him unsettles her and brings back to the surface those feelings of unrequited love she’s held for Jesse throughout the years, and so begins their story.

‘Unrequited love. Was there anything more painful?’

Emery Rose perfectly captured the beauty and pain of first love and unrequited love. She captured the torment and passion of closure and moving on, and she created a story where the path to true love wasn’t just rocky but paved with boulder-sized obstacles that sent our hearts on a roller coaster of emotions.

‘Love makes you reckless. All logic and reason flew out the window, and you let your emotions take the driver’s seat. You took your chances, pretending to be brave while you ignored the consequences. That’s how it was for me, anyway.’

We felt it all, the push and the resistance, the love and the anguish, in a story that gave us those ‘old school‘ vibes that reminds us why we love this genre. There’s nothing like torturing your heart, only to have it healed in the most wonderful way, and topping it off with an epilogue that was perfection!


What happens when the love of your life refuses to love you back?

Jesse McCallister.
Motocross legend. Reckless heartbreaker. And the love of my life.
Too bad he only thought of me as his best friend’s little sister.
Naïve and innocent. Only eighteen. Completely off-limits.

Unrequited love… was there anything more painful?
Turns out there was—when he kisses you but has no memory of it.
When he tells you his heart was broken, and he doesn’t believe in love.
When he doesn’t want you kissing anyone else, but you’re stuck in the friend zone.

Despite the odds stacked against us, my foolish heart refused to stop loving him.
Now I’m falling under his spell. Drowning in his perfect lies. Addicted to his stolen glances and forbidden kisses.
I’m on a collision course with disaster and only one thing is certain… Jesse McCallister is going to ruin me.

Purchase Here:

Share This Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest Posts


“Just don’t fall in love with me,” I teased. “Kay.” He said.


‘Sometimes passion was a whisper, other times a roar. This time? It was a storm.’


“Part of me wants to pretend I have you, but another part thinks I’ll die if you don’t tell me you love me, even if it doesn’t change anything. Even if it’s just getting to hear it one more time.”


‘It’s such a simple word – just four letters. Home. But there aren’t enough letters in the alphabet in the world to capture the meaning of it.’

SWEET MEMORY (The Painted Daisies #1) by LJ EVANS

“I’m afraid I’ll fall completely, head-over-heels in love with you, and that you’ll fall back. I’m afraid we’ll discover we’re the missing pieces of each other’s souls.
The words had a beat -a rhythm- like it was a song she’d already written.

Featured Author

COLLEEN HOOVER captured our hearts back in 2011 with her unique, warm, funny, sweet, and utterly captivating stories. Our love affair with this incredibly talented author has never waned. Colleen is one in a million!

Upcoming Releases

Be sure to keep updated on all the books headed our way by visiting our TBB Upcoming Releases Page.

Latest New Releases

We’ve got all the latest releases, so be sure to head on over to our New Releases Page!


We’ve got some amazing books currently on sale! Be sure to hop on over to our sales page and check them out!

TotallyBooked Shop

Have you checked out the fabulous items available in our shop? The Tote Bag is perfect for book signings! <3

On Facebook

SuperWebTricks Loading...

On Twitter

Follow me on Twitter

On Instagram

The Totally Booked Blog Shop

Browse Our Shop »

On Facebook

SuperWebTricks Loading...

On Twitter

Follow me on Twitter

On Instagram

Keep In Touch!

Subscribe For Updates

Subscribe for Updates